A Review of the Assessment Methods of Voice Disorders in the Context of Parkinson's Disease
Keywords:Parkinson’s Disease, Voice Analysis, Speech Processing, Parkinson’s Disease Assessment,
AbstractIn recent years, a significant progress in the field of research dedicated to the treatment of disabilities has been witnessed. This is particularly true for neurological diseases, which generally influence the system that controls the execution of learned motor patterns. In addition to its importance for communication with the outside world and interaction with others, the voice is a reflection of our personality, moods and emotions. It is a way to provide information on health status, shape, intentions, age and even the social environment. It is also a working tool for many, but an important element of life for all. Patients with Parkinson’s disease (PD) are numerous and they suffer from hypokinetic dysarthria, which is manifested in all aspects of speech production: respiration, phonation, articulation, nasalization and prosody. This paper provides a review of the methods of the assessment of speech disorders in the context of PD and also discusses the limitations.
Van Den Eeden, Stephen K., et al. "Incidence of Parkinson’s disease: variation by age, gender, and race/ethnicity." American journal of epidemiology 157.11 (2003): 1015-1022.
Sakar, Betul Erdogdu, et al. "Collection and Analysis of a Parkinson Speech Dataset With Multiple Types of Sound Recordings." Biomedical and Health Informatics, IEEE Journal of 17.4 (2013): 828-834.
De Lau, Lonneke ML, and Monique Breteler. "Epidemiology of Parkinson's disease." The Lancet Neurology 5.6 (2006): 525-535.
Little, Max A., et al. "Suitability of dysphonia measurements for telemonitoring of Parkinson's disease." Biomedical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on 56.4 (2009): 1015-1022.
Huse, Daniel M., et al. "Burden of illness in Parkinson's disease." Movement disorders 20.11 (2005): 1449-1454.
Lasierra, Nelia, et al. "Lessons learned after a three-year store and forward teledermatology experience using internet: Strengths and limitations."International journal of medical informatics 81.5 (2012): 332-343.
Andersen, Tariq, et al. "Designing for collaborative interpretation in telemonitoring: Re-introducing patients as diagnostic agents." International journal of medical informatics 80.8 (2011): e112-e126.
Mandal, Indrajit, and N. Sairam. "Accurate telemonitoring of Parkinson's disease diagnosis using robust inference system." International journal of medical informatics 82.5 (2013): 359-377.
Abramson, Erika L., et al. "Physician experiences transitioning between an older versus newer electronic health record for electronic prescribing."International journal of medical informatics 81.8 (2012): 539-548.
Bernard, Erik, et al. "Internet use for information seeking in clinical practice: a cross-sectional survey among French general practitioners." International journal of medical informatics 81.7
Loukas, Constantinos, and Peter Brown. "A PC-based system for predicting movement from deep brain signals in Parkinson's disease." Computer methods and programs in biomedicine 107.1 (2012): 36-44.
Farnikova, Katerina, Alois Krobot, and Petr Kanovsky. "Musculoskeletal problems as an initial manifestation of Parkinson's disease: A retrospective study." Journal of the neurological sciences 319.1 (2012): 102-104.
Romenets, Silvia Rios, et al. "Rapid eye movement sleep behavior disorder and subtypes of Parkinson's disease." Movement Disorders 27.8 (2012): 996-1003.
Delaney, Mary, Jane Simpson, and Iracema Leroi. "Perceptions of cause and control of impulse control behaviours in people with Parkinson's disease."British journal of health psychology 17.3 (2012): 522-535.
Ho, Aileen K., et al. "Speech impairment in a large sample of patients with Parkinson’s disease." Behavioural neurology 11.3 (1999): 131-137.
Logemann, Jeri A., et al. "Frequency and cooccurrence of vocal tract dysfunctions in the speech of a large sample of Parkinson patients." Journal of Speech and Hearing Disorders 43.1 (1978): 47-57.
O'Sullivan, S. B., and T. J. Schmitz. "Parkinson disease,‖ Physical Rehabilitation." (2007): 856-894.
Duffy, Joseph R. Motor speech disorders: Substrates, differential diagnosis, and management. Elsevier Health Sciences, 2012.
Sapir, Shimon, et al. "Effects of intensive voice treatment (the Lee Silverman Voice Treatment [LSVT]) on vowel articulation in dysarthric individuals with idiopathic Parkinson disease: acoustic and perceptual findings." Journal of Speech, Language, and Hearing Research 50.4 (2007): 899-912.
Rahn III, Douglas A., et al. "Phonatory impairment in Parkinson's disease: evidence from nonlinear dynamic analysis and perturbation analysis." Journal of Voice 21.1 (2007): 64-71.
Jankovic, Joseph. "Parkinson’s disease: clinical features and diagnosis."Journal of Neurology, Neurosurgery & Psychiatry 79.4 (2008): 368-376.
Viallet, François, and Bernard Teston. "La dysarthrie dans la maladie de Parkinson." Les dysarthries (2007): 169-174.
Manciocco, Arianna, et al. "The application of Russell and Burch 3R principle in rodent models of neurodegenerative disease: the case of Parkinson’s disease."Neuroscience & Biobehavioral Reviews 33.1 (2009): 18-32.
Wilkins, E. J., et al. "A DNA resequencing array for genes involved in Parkinson’s disease." Parkinsonism & related disorders 18.4 (2012): 386-390.
Niu, L., et al. "Effect of bilateral deep brain stimulation of the subthalamic nucleus on freezing of gait in Parkinson's disease." Journal of International Medical Research 40.3 (2012): 1108-1113.
Lin, Xian, et al. "Conditional expression of Parkinson's disease-related mutant α-synuclein in the midbrain dopaminergic neurons causes progressive neurodegeneration and degradation of transcription factor nuclear receptor related 1." The Journal of Neuroscience 32.27 (2012): 9248-9264.
Tang, Lanhua, et al. "Meta-analysis of association between PITX3 gene polymorphism and Parkinson's disease." Journal of the neurological sciences317.1 (2012): 80-86.
Langston, J. William. "Parkinson’s disease: current and future challenges."Neurotoxicology 23.4 (2002): 443-450.
, Hui-Ling, et al. "An efficient diagnosis system for detection of Parkinson’s disease using fuzzy k-nearest neighbor approach." Expert Systems with Applications 40.1 (2013): 263-271.
Jafari, Ayyoob. "Classification of Parkinson’s disease patients using nonlinear phonetic features and Mel-Frequency Cepstral analysis." Biomedical Engineering: Applications, Basis and Communications 25.04 (2013).
Tsanas, Athanasios, et al. "Objective automatic assessment of rehabilitative speech treatment in Parkinson's disease." Neural systems and rehabilitation engineering, IEEE Transactions on, (2014) Vol 22, No 1.
Teston, Bernard, François Viallet, and Praticien hospitalier PhD. "La dysprosodie parkinsonienne." Ozsancak, C.; Auzou, P.(éds) Les troubles de la parole et de la déglutition dans la maladie de Parkinson, Marseille: Solal (2005): 161-193.
Conte, A., et al. "Botulinum toxin A modulates afferent fibers in neurogenic detrusor overactivity." European Journal of Neurology 19.5 (2012): 725-732.
Ramig, Lorraine Olson, et al. "Intensive speech treatment for patients with Parkinson's disease Short-and long-term comparison of two techniques."Neurology 47.6 (1996): 1496-1504.
Ramig, Lorraine O., et al. "Changes in vocal loudness following intensive voice treatment (LSVT®) in individuals with Parkinson's disease: A comparison with untreated patients and normal age‐matched controls." Movement Disorders 16.1 (2001): 79-83.
De Swart, Bert JM, et al. "Improvement of voicing in patients with Parkinson’s disease by speech therapy." Neurology 60.3 (2003): 498-500.
Baken, Ronald J., and Robert F. Orlikoff. Clinical measurement of speech and voice. Cengage Learning, 2000.
Dejonckere, Philippe H., et al. "A basic protocol for functional assessment of voice pathology, especially for investigating the efficacy of (phonosurgical) treatments and evaluating new assessment techniques." European Archives of Oto-rhino-laryngology 258.2 (2001): 77-82.
Little, Max A., et al. "Exploiting nonlinear recurrence and fractal scaling properties for voice disorder detection." BioMedical Engineering OnLine 6.1 (2007): 23.
Alonso, Jesus B., et al. "Automatic detection of pathologies in the voice by HOS based parameters." EURASIP Journal on Applied Signal Processing 4 (2001): 275-284.
Hansen, John HL, Liliana Gavidia-Ceballos, and James F. Kaiser. "A nonlinear operator-based speech feature analysis method with application to vocal fold pathology assessment." Biomedical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on 45.3 (1998): 300-313.
Cnockaert, Laurence, et al. "Low-frequency vocal modulations in vowels produced by Parkinsonian subjects." Speech communication 50.4 (2008): 288-300.
Godino-Llorente, Juan Ignacio, and P. Gomez-Vilda. "Automatic detection of voice impairments by means of short-term cepstral parameters and neural network based detectors." Biomedical Engineering, IEEE Transactions on 51.2 (2004): 380-384.
Boersma, Paul. "Praat, a system for doing phonetics by computer." Glot international 5.9/10 (2002): 341-345.
Elemetrics, Kay. "Multi-Dimensional Voice Program (MDVP).[Computer program.]." Pine Brook, NJ: Author (1993).
Tsanas, Athanasios, et al. "Enhanced classical dysphonia measures and sparse regression for telemonitoring of Parkinson's disease progression."Acoustics Speech and Signal Processing (ICASSP), 2010 IEEE International Conference on. IEEE, 2010.
Hariharan, Muthusamy, Kemal Polat, and Ravindran Sindhu. "A new hybrid intelligent system for accurate detection of Parkinson's disease." Computer methods and programs in biomedicine 113.3 (2014): 904-913.
Zuo, Wan-Li, et al. "Effective detection of Parkinson's disease using an adaptive fuzzy< i> k-nearest neighbor approach." Biomedical Signal Processing and Control 8.4 (2013): 364-373.
Zwirner, Petra, Thomas Murry, and Gayle E. Woodson. "Phonatory function of neurologically impaired patients." Journal of communication disorders 24.4 (1991): 287-300.
Kantz, Holger, and Thomas Schreiber. Nonlinear time series analysis. Vol. 7. Cambridge university press, 2004.
Laver, John. Principles of phonetics. Cambridge University Press, 1994.
Locco, Julie. La production des occlusives dans la maladie de Parkinson. Diss. Aix Marseille 1, 2005.
Teston, Bernard. "L'évaluation objective des dysfonctionnements de la voix et de la parole; 2e partie: les dysphonies." Travaux Interdisciplinaires du Laboratoire Parole et Langage d'Aix-en-Pro
Caroline Fortin. Le visuel du corps humain: Français-anglais. Montréal, Québec Amérique, 2009.
Hastie, Trevor, et al. "The elements of statistical learning: data mining, inference and prediction." The Mathematical Intelligencer 27.2 (2005): 83-85.
Guyon, Isabelle, and André Elisseeff. "An introduction to variable and feature selection." The Journal of Machine Learning Research 3 (2003): 1157-1182.
Learning Repository, U.C.I.: http://archive.ics.uci.edu/ml/, June 2008
Shahbaba, Babak, and Radford Neal. "Nonlinear models using Dirichlet process mixtures." The Journal of Machine Learning Research 10 (2009): 1829-1850.
Das, Resul. "A comparison of multiple classification methods for diagnosis of Parkinson disease." Expert Systems with Applications 37.2 (2010): 1568-1572.
Klein, John P., and Mei‐Jie Zhang. Survival analysis, software. John Wiley & Sons, Ltd, 2005.
Singh, Neha, Viness Pillay, and Yahya E. Choonara. "Advances in the treatment of Parkinson's disease." Progress in neurobiology 81.1 (2007): 29-44.
Guo, Pei-Fang, Prabir Bhattacharya, and Nawwaf Kharma. "Advances in detecting Parkinson’s disease." Medical Biometrics. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2010. 306-314.
Sakar, C. Okan, and Olcay Kursun. "Telediagnosis of Parkinson’s disease using measurements of dysphonia." Journal of medical systems 34.4 (2010): 591-599.
Ozcift, Akin, and Arif Gulten. "Classifier ensemble construction with rotation forest to improve medical diagnosis performance of machine learning algorithms." Computer methods and programs in biomedicine 104.3 (2011): 443-451.
Åström, Freddie, and Rasit Koker. "A parallel neural network approach to prediction of Parkinson’s Disease." Expert systems with applications 38.10 (2011): 12470-12474.
Spadoto, André A., et al. "Improving Parkinson's disease identification through evolutionary-based feature selection." Engineering in Medicine and Biology Society, EMBC, 2011 Annual International Conference of the IEEE. IEEE, 2011.
Li, Der-Chiang, Chiao-Wen Liu, and Susan C. Hu. "A fuzzy-based data transformation for feature extraction to increase classification performance with small medical data sets." Artificial Intelligence in Medicine 52.1 (2011): 45-52.
Tenório, Josceli Maria, et al. "Artificial intelligence techniques applied to the development of a decision–support system for diagnosing celiac disease."International journal of medical informatics 80.11 (2011): 793-802.
Torii, Manabu, et al. "An exploratory study of a text classification framework for Internet-based surveillance of emerging epidemics." International journal of medical informatics 80.1 (2011): 56-66.
Krishnapuram, Balaji, et al. "Sparse multinomial logistic regression: Fast algorithms and generalization bounds." Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, IEEE Transactions on 27.6 (2005): 957-968.
Friedman, Jerome, Trevor Hastie, and Robert Tibshirani. "Additive logistic regression: a statistical view of boosting (with discussion and a rejoinder by the authors)." The annals of statistics 28.2 (2000): 337-407.
Gutiérrez, Pedro Antonio, César Hervás-Martínez, and Francisco J.
Martínez-Estudillo. "Logistic regression by means of evolutionary radial basis function neural networks." Neural Networks, IEEE Transactions on 22.2 (2011): 246-263.
Mandal, I. "Software reliability assessment using artificial neural network."Proceedings of the International Conference and Workshop on Emerging Trends in Technology. ACM, 2010.
Rodriguez, Juan José, Ludmila I. Kuncheva, and Carlos J. Alonso. "Rotation forest: A new classifier ensemble method." Pattern Analysis and Machine Intelligence, IEEE Transactions on 28.10 (2006): 1619-1630.
Mandal, Indrajit, and N. Sairam. "Accurate prediction of coronary artery disease using reliable diagnosis system." Journal of medical systems 36.5 (2012): 3353-3373.
Beaudoin, Christopher E., and Traci Hong. "Health information seeking, diet and physical activity: an empirical assessment by medium and critical demographics." International journal of medical informatics 80.8 (2011): 586-595.
Sandberg, Kristian. "The haar wavelet transform." Applied Math Website-Welcome to the Department of Applied Mathematics (2000).
Tu, Chiu-Chuan, and Chia-Feng Juang. "Recurrent type-2 fuzzy neural network using Haar wavelet energy and entropy features for speech detection in noisy environments." Expert Systems with Applications 39.3 (2012): 2479-2488.
Ozcift, Akin. "SVM feature selection based rotation forest ensemble classifiers to improve computer-aided diagnosis of Parkinson disease." Journal of medical systems 36.4 (2012): 2141-2147.
Eberhart, Russ C., and James Kennedy. "A new optimizer using particle swarm theory." Proceedings of the sixth international symposium on micro machine and human science. Vol. 1. 1995.
Chen, Hui-Ling, et al. "An adaptive fuzzy k-nearest neighbor method based on parallel particle swarm optimization for bankruptcy prediction." Advances in Knowledge Discovery and Data Mining. Springer Berlin Heidelberg, 2011. 249-264.
Chen, Hui-Ling, et al. "A novel bankruptcy prediction model based on an adaptive fuzzy< i> k-nearest neighbor method." Knowledge-Based Systems24.8 (2011): 1348-1359.
Keller, James M., Michael R. Gray, and James A. Givens. "A fuzzy k-nearest neighbor algorithm." Systems, Man and Cybernetics, IEEE Transactions on 4 (1985): 580-585.
Hariharan, Muthusamy, Kemal Polat, and Ravindran Sindhu. "A new hybrid intelligent system for accurate detection of Parkinson's disease." Computer methods and programs in biomedicine 113.3 (2014): 904-913.
Benba, Achraf, Abdelilah Jilbab, and Ahmed Hammouch. "Voice analysis for detecting persons with Parkinson’s disease using MFCC and VQ." The 2014 International Conference on Circuits, Systems and Signal Processing. Saint Petersburg, Russia, September 23-25, 2014.
Benba, Achraf, Abdelilah Jilbab, and Ahmed Hammouch. "Voice analysis for detecting persons with Parkinson’s disease using PLP and VQ." Journal of Theoretical and Applied Information Technology 70.3 (2014).
Benba, Achraf, Abdelilah Jilbab, and Ahmed Hammouch. "Voiceprint analysis using Perceptual Linear Prediction and Support Vector Machines for detecting persons with Parkinson’s disease." the 3rd International Conference on Health Science and Biomedical Systems, Florence, Italy, November 22-24, 2014
Achraf Benba, Abdelilah Jilbab and Ahmed Hammouch. “Hybridization of best acoustic cues for detecting persons with Parkinson’s disease,” The 2nd World conference on complex system, Agadir, Morocco, 2014.
Skodda, Sabine, Heiko Rinsche, and Uwe Schlegel. "Progression of dysprosody in Parkinson's disease over time—a longitudinal study." Movement Disorders 24.5 (2009): 716-722.
Goetz, Christopher G., et al. "Testing objective measures of motor impairment in early Parkinson's disease: Feasibility study of an at‐home testing device." Movement Disorders 24.4 (2009): 551-556.
Teston, Bernard. "L'évaluation objective des dysfonctionnements de la voix et de la parole; 1ère partie: les dysarthries." Travaux Interdisciplinaires du Laboratoire Parole et Langage d'Aix-en-Provence (TIPA) 19 (2000): 115-154.
Hammarberg, Britta, et al. "Perceptual and acoustic correlates of abnormal voice qualities." Acta oto-laryngologica 90.1-6 (1980): 441-451.
Hirano, M. "Psycho-acoustic evaluation of voice: GRBAS scale for evaluating the hoarse voice. Clinican Examination of Voice." New York, Springer-Verlab (1981).
Dejonckere, P. H., et al. "Perceptual evaluation of dysphonia: reliability and relevance." Folia Phoniatrica et Logopaedica 45.2 (1993): 76-83.
Fahn, S. E. R. L., Elton, R. L., Marsden, C. D., Calne, D. B., & Golstein, M. (1987). Recent development in Parkinson's disease. Floram Park, NJ Macmilian Health Care Information.
Weismer, Gary. "Acoustic descriptions of dysarthric speech: Perceptual correlates and physiological inferences." Seminars in speech and language. Vol. 5. No. 04. © 1984 by Thieme Medical Publishers, Inc., 1984.
Ramaker, Claudia, et al. "Systematic evaluation of rating scales for impairment and disability in Parkinson's disease." Movement Disorders 17.5 (2002): 867-876.
Rousselot, Pierre Jean. Principes de phonétique expérimentale. Vol. 1. H. Welter, 1901.
Warren, D. W. "Regulation of speech aerodynamics." Principles of experimental phonetics (1996): 46-92.
Warren, Donald W. "Aerodynamics of speech production." Contemporary issues in experimental phonetics 30 (1976): 105-137.
Farrús, Mireia, Javier Hernando, and Pascual Ejarque. "Jitter and shimmer measurements for speaker recognition." INTERSPEECH. 2007.
Shirvan, R. Arefi, and E. Tahami. "Voice analysis for detecting Parkinson's disease using genetic algorithm and KNN classification method." Biomedical Engineering (ICBME), 2011 18th Iranian Conference of. IEEE, 2011.
Yumoto, Eiji, Wilbur J. Gould, and Thomas Baer. "Harmonics‐to‐noise ratio as an index of the degree of hoarseness." The journal of the Acoustical Society of America 71.6 (1982): 1544-1550.
Kasuya, Hideki, et al. "Normalized noise energy as an acoustic measure to evaluate pathologic voice." The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 80.5 (1986): 1329-1334.
Qi, Yingyong, et al. "Minimizing the effect of period determination on the computation of amplitude perturbation in voice." The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 97.4 (1995): 2525-2532.
Fraile, Rubén, et al. "MFCC-based Remote Pathology Detection on Speech Transmitted Through the Telephone Channel-Impact of Linear Distortions: Band Limitation, Frequency Response and Noise." BIOSIGNALS. 2009.
Murphy, Peter J., and Olatunji O. Akande. "Quantification of glottal and voiced speech harmonics-to-noise ratios using cepstral-based estimation." ISCA Tutorial and Research Workshop (ITRW) on Non-Linear Speech Processing. 2005.
Hasan, Md Rashidul, et al. "Speaker identification using mel frequency cepstral coefficients." 3rd International Conference on Electrical & Computer Engineering ICECE. Vol. 2004. 2004.
Kapoor, Tripti, and R. K. Sharma. "Parkinson’s disease Diagnosis using Mel-frequency Cepstral Coefficients and Vector Quantization." International Journal of Computer Applications 14.3 (2011): 43-46.
Pouchoulin, Gilles, et al. "Frequency study for the characterization of the dysphonic voices." Proceedings of INTERSPEECH 2007 (2007): 1198-1201.
Fraile, R., et al. "Use of mel-frequency cepstral coefficients for automatic pathology detection on sustained vowel phonations: mathematical and statistical justification." Proc. 4th international symposium on image/video communications over fixed and mobile networks, Bilbao, Brazil. 2008.
Dibazar, Alireza A., S. Narayanan, and Theodore W. Berger. "Feature analysis for automatic detection of pathological speech." Engineering in Medicine and Biology, 2002. 24th Annual Conference and the Annual Fall Meeting of the Biomedical Engineering Society EMBS/BMES Conference, 2002. Proceedings of the Second Joint. Vol. 1. IEEE, 2002.
Hermansky, Hynek. "Perceptual linear predictive (PLP) analysis of speech." the Journal of the Acoustical Society of America 87.4 (1990): 1738-1752.
Baker, Kristin K., et al. "Thyroarytenoid muscle activity associated with hypophonia in Parkinson disease and aging." Neurology 51.6 (1998): 1592-1598.
Stelzig, Y., et al. "[Laryngeal manifestations in patients with Parkinson disease]." Laryngo-rhino-otologie 78.10 (1999): 544-551.
Perez, Kathe S., et al. "The Parkinson larynx: tremor and videostroboscopic findings." Journal of Voice 10.4 (1996): 354-361.
Gentil, Michkle. "Acoustic characteristics of speech in Friedreich’s disease."Folia Phoniatrica et Logopaedica 42.3 (1990): 125-134.
How to Cite
TRANSFER OF COPYRIGHT AGREEMENT
The manuscript is herewith submitted for publication in the Journal of Telecommunication, Electronic and Computer Engineering (JTEC). It has not been published before, and it is not under consideration for publication in any other journals. It contains no material that is scandalous, obscene, libelous or otherwise contrary to law. When the manuscript is accepted for publication, I, as the author, hereby agree to transfer to JTEC, all rights including those pertaining to electronic forms and transmissions, under existing copyright laws, except for the following, which the author(s) specifically retain(s):
- All proprietary right other than copyright, such as patent rights
- The right to make further copies of all or part of the published article for my use in classroom teaching
- The right to reuse all or part of this manuscript in a compilation of my own works or in a textbook of which I am the author; and
- The right to make copies of the published work for internal distribution within the institution that employs me
I agree that copies made under these circumstances will continue to carry the copyright notice that appears in the original published work. I agree to inform my co-authors, if any, of the above terms. I certify that I have obtained written permission for the use of text, tables, and/or illustrations from any copyrighted source(s), and I agree to supply such written permission(s) to JTEC upon request.